What is Progress?

Before I left New York I had wanted to see Tino Seghale’s piece “This Progress” at the Guggenheim – the show (and his work) sounded intriguing but I ran out of time before we left. But the question as described from reviews of the show – “What is progress?” – has stayed with me, and I’ve been wondering how I would have responded to it. For me it depends on what day you’d ask me about it. And it’s been rolling around in my head as we’ve been in Singapore. The more time I spend here the more I feel like the people here have a pretty sure answer to that question figured out.

Everything feels shiny, new, and of the future. When we visited one of the malls I seriously felt like I was stepping into some kind of idealized, uber hip parallel universe of America. It seems like anything that’s older than twenty years old is getting knocked down and replaced with sleek glass and steel boxes or crazy weird shaped blobs straight out of Bladerunner; the skyline is literally a forest of cranes. 

We even encountered a public exhibition in a government building for the “Draft Master Plan 2008”, which described plans for each sector of the island over the next 10-20 years. It was like an urban planning student’s ultimate fantasy, with giant dioramas describing how everything is going to be more efficient, fun and beneficial through massive yet careful changes to the existing landscape. The city and the people just seem so sure about where things are going and that Singapore is forging ahead and making itself relevant on a massively global scale.

A change like this in such a short period of time seems impossible, but it is going to be a reality whether everyone is on the boat about it or not. However I do suppose that it’s slightly easier to do on an island of 4 million people under a benevolent dictatorship than a country of 300 million people spread across thousands of miles that can’t even agree on health care. At any rate, it’s fascinating to see how people define progress and how they act on it. Or not. We’re now on our way to northern Thailand (where the internet is not by any means ubiquitous) to participate in a sustainability study tour, and I think we’ll be getting a very different viewpoint on what “progress” is.



5 thoughts on “What is Progress?

  1. One of the two major political parties in the US defines its core philosophy as preventing anything from changing, so with that anchor holding us back, it’s particularly difficult to plan for any future improvements. Our cities are also "colonized" by the rural and suburban areas, whose inefficient infrastructure is paid for by the extra wealth generated in our cities. (NYC in particular pays $10 billion per year more in taxes than it receives in services from the State, and another $10 billion from the feds.)

  2. Anonymous says:

    I think part of it also has to be due to the fact that the leadership in Singapore and many other Asian countries have a more authoritarian bent. If they say something, the people follow. This is definitely not a bad thing, as the government can give focus and a general vision for everyone… and be leaders. Over here, there are so many competing interests and most try to be generally accomodating towards other views.

  3. Julie Lee says:

    Everybody view progress differently; the control progress in Singapore certainly is a lot easier than US. But you have to give up some freedom to exchange for that progress. I can’t say it is better than the US or not because I have not live there long term. I always feel that I am lucky to be in the US because it has given me my progress. I feel if I remained in Hong Kong I would not have done as well. The US system certainly is not perfect but I appreciate the opportunity it gives to many immigrants so they can make their own progress.

  4. Anonymous says:

    I agree with Mom that everyone views progress differently. When you come to Germany, you will see it’s come a long way from being a divided country, but at the same time, the east still lags behind the west. On the other hand, does knocking down and building for the future mean progress if it’s erasing the past? When you are in China, you will see that too…many of the old hutong and old neighborhoods are getting replaced by skyscrapers and people are getting pushed out. China’s making itself relevant in the world too like Singapore, as you said, but it’s at the expense of many people who have lived there for generations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s